My daughter, Kara, is incredibly tenacious – has been since taking her first breath 10 years ago. As an infant, she screamed her head off whenever I tried to lay her down, unless I cocooned her around my boob so she could nurse every 20 minutes. As a toddler, she rejected clothing because it was too constraining – the sock felt wonky, the shirt was itchy, the panties crept too much, and the shoelaces were idiotic. She refused to sleep in my bed, didn’t like her own bed, and, so, the bedtime battle rallied on until she was in kindergarten. Her preschool years brought more eruption – sulks and squawks about clothing, bedtime, food touching on her plate, you name it…
When she was in kindergarten, she insisted on riding the bus to school with her friends, but we lived too close for the bussing option; so some days, I walked her to school, and other days, I drove her. Well, one day when I arrived to pick her up, she wasn't there. I parked, went inside, and checked her classroom; no Kara. I walked to the office, she wasn’t there either. I talked with the principal and then headed home to see if she had decided to walk on her own, which, at five-years-old was against the rules. When she still wasn’t home, I immediately called the school and notified the principal, who insisted I give her a few minutes to question the staff before I notified police. A few moments later, the principal called and informed me that Kara had hopped on a bus with her friend, and said the driver would wait for me at the next bus stop.
I was as petrified as I was angry, and relieved, of course, that she hadn’t been hit by a car, or snatched up by a pedophile, but when I questioned her as to why she would do such a thing after I repeatedly explained the bus situation, her only response was, “…because I wanted to ride the bus!”
Yeah, when Kara gets an idea in her head, she’s like a dog with a bone between its jowls: ferocious, relentless, theatrical.
While I certainly did not condone her dictating to me, correcting such hardheaded behavior was difficult, and, I admit, I wobbled on that tightrope between too much discipline, and not enough, for quite awhile. I didn’t want to squash her independent spirit or make her feel devalued when she expressed her desires and opinions so freely, so frequently, and with such conviction; but, she had to learn that I was in control and would not tolerate disappearing acts or disrespect. I expected her to articulate herself without screaming, follow the rules, and be polite.
Her dad’s answer to everything was, “whip her ass!” which was, by the way, one of many things we disagreed on and a huge source of tension long after we divorced. It continues to be.
After attempting what seemed like several thousand anxiety ridden tactics, which left me worn out, I learned what worked with Kara and what didn’t.
I recruited her kindergarten teacher to aid in my mission to get her sleeping in her own room, which worked wonderfully, as did the warning of a proposed phone call to her teacher in the midst of her blowups over getting ready for school. I learned to listen to what she was really saying instead of habitually barking orders, which helped her to feel understood, even when the answer was still no. And, more times than not, I let go and allowed her to freely experience the natural consequences of her behavior.
If she wanted to wear the same pair of pants to school every single day for a week, then she learned to deal with kids making fun of her. If she refused to wear a jacket outside, she dealt with being cold. If she didn’t like what I made for dinner, she made herself something different and cleaned up her own mess. If she refused to clean her room, everything lying around was gone when she came home from school. If she went to the park with her friends and didn’t return home at the agreed time, she didn’t go next time. When she flew off the handle, I sent her to her room, where she had to stay until she calmed down to have a civil discussion.
I learned the hard way the importance of saying what I meant, meaning what I said, and following through with consequences; she learned the hard way that I was serious about enforcing rules.
I learned that mastering the fine art of picking our battles is probably one of the most vital strategies for parents when dealing with children who have reached a willful level of autonomy and exude a resistance to rules, and those battles will differ from child to child, as Corbin continues to remind me with his exhausting toddler shenanigans.
Through the years, my kids have taught me that effective parenting requires we continuously navigate sticky waters with each new phase they go through, coming out the other side with our sanity, and theirs, intact. What worked last week may not necessarily carry as much weight next month, and, quite honestly, some things just aren’t worth fighting about. While one parent may deem certain issues enormously important, another parent has disengaged from the fight; opting instead for peace.
Sometimes, we need to take a step back and ask ourselves, is fighting this battle worth it? Perhaps you will discover, just as I did, that by giving a little in some areas you will have a happier, more peaceful family.










