I had no idea, 21 months and 19 days ago, that parental alienation existed. I had never before heard the term, and, to be honest, I’m still not entirely convinced that is what’s happening.
Yes, I am physically separated from my children by 279 miles. I’m in Ohio; they moved to Indiana with their Dad in June 2008. Yes, my children were physically isolated from me from October 2008 until July 31, 2010 – 656 days of isolation, in fact, for reasons still unknown to me. Yes, their mail was intercepted; gifts were not given to them; repeatedly, phone calls went unanswered. Yes, I was continually told that my children were ‘happier than they’ve ever been’ and ‘they don’t need you’ and ‘you need to back off.’
No, they weren’t allowed to initiate phone contact – they still aren’t. No, they weren’t allowed to send me a Mother’s Day card, birthday card, or acknowledge my existence on major holidays – they still aren’t. No, they weren’t allowed to send me school photos, copies of their report cards, or in any way keep me updated as to significant happenings in their lives. No, I am not listed as their Mother in school records, as their Father - the one who enrolled them in that Indiana school district- purposefully left me off, instead listing his then-girlfriend, now new wife, as my children’s other parent.
In the beginning, however, they were allowed to openly express their love and affection for me, and did so during our daily, and then weekly, phone calls. In the beginning, they were allowed to come home, although it was not even close to what my ex promised when he left the state. In the beginning, our phone conversations and time together was relaxed and without tension, but as time progressed, and I was relegated to only infrequent, sporadic telephone contact, I began noticing subtle changes in the girls’ demeanor.
Shortly after the New Year 2009, for example, my once loving and expressive daughters began to sound emotionless and reserved, spoke in flat, monotone voices, and only answered my questions with ‘yes’ or ‘no’. That is how they continue to respond today. They feel, for whatever reason, they cannot elaborate on any particular topic. Asking them a simple question, such as, ‘what did you have for breakfast?’ produces an incredible amount of anxiety in them – long pauses – as if they are afraid to answer. Often, I change the subject in an attempt to break the silence and keep the conversation flowing, but the undertone I get is ‘get me off this phone!’ Several times I questioned them, asking ‘are you feeling okay?’ ‘Is there something wrong?’ ‘Did something happen that I need to know about?’ And the answer is always the same, “I’m just tired!” While that may have worked once or twice, it didn’t sit well with me a year ago, and certainly doesn’t sit well with me today.
In May 2009, their behavior advanced to yelling at me over the phone, hanging up on me, and refusing to answer when I called back. I was horrified, of course, and confused, hurt – literally speechless. I sat in complete silence, clenching the phone with a dropped jaw, replaying the conversation in my mind. I knew I hadn’t said anything that would even come close to deserving that type of inappropriate response. I had no idea as to the source of their hostility, but they certainly perceived something I said, or did, as a slight against them.
Reaching out to their Dad was basically unproductive, as I was told they were ‘hormonal’ and Kara was ‘upset’ because the card I sent her wasn’t as good as the one I sent to her sister. I didn’t believe it then; certainly, I don’t believe it now. Tearfully, I pleaded with him for his support. I knew if anybody could get through to them, it would be him.
Little did I know, he already had.
We had a court order in effect. My Ex has, and had, actual knowledge of its terms. But, he continued to encroach on my parenting time with the girls – for eight months he deliberately scheduled countless family events and social activities for the girls during my parenting time – before finally sending me an email last summer informing me that until I took him back to court, I wouldn’t be allowed to see them, but that I should feel free to call them whenever I wanted.
Again, I sat dismayed, and, apparently oblivious to what was happening. Once again, I reached out to him by phone and email, begging, pleading with him to do the right thing for our daughters. He laughed. He was arrogant and self-righteous, and told me I needed to get on with my life and not worry about HIS kids. They are fine, he said, happier than they’ve ever been.
When he was notified that I had filed the necessary paperwork to not only enforce our court order, but to have him held in contempt for purposeful interference with my parenting time (among other things), his initial reaction was, “oh, that’s nice. What took you so long?” When it became evident that I was not going to dismiss contempt against him, despite several attempts on his part to manipulate me into submission, he became infuriated and began threatening to move the girls once again, change his phone number, and completely cut me out of their lives. That’s when I filed for full custody.
This ordeal has been pure torture. I feel, at times, like a piece of my soul has been ripped from deep within me; everyday, I feel their absence in some profound way and long to see them, touch them, kiss and hug them. At times, the pain is so thick it is hard to breathe.
I feel an enormous amount of guilt, too, because I did not have the resources available to secure an attorney or file paperwork sooner. For almost a year I felt hopeless to protect my children from their poisonous environment, and those highly charged emotions took a toll on the life I still had to live. Every single day felt never ending, especially during the dark and gloomy winter while my husband was laid off. I felt as though I were sinking bit by bit into a deep, dark hole. I held my breathe and hung on for dear life, praying for strength to get through the dark winter, praying for wisdom, praying to be guided in the right direction, praying for the patience to make it through till spring.
Not knowing if the girls’ behavior was related to age or environment, I began researching pre-teen behaviors, bought and read parenting books, and then came across an article about parental alienation. I discovered a wealth of information and utilized the recommended resources to keep in contact with my daughters until I was in a better position – actions that should have reduced the amount of anxiety they experienced during phone calls. However, that didn’t seem to help much either. I later found out that the weekly cards and letters had not been delivered, and my lack of phone contact meant to decrease anxiety only heightened anger and the ex used this to further his twisted agenda.
While I don’t believe my daughters suffer from parental alienation syndrome – because they are capable of showing warmth and love when they come home, despite their lack of interest and disrespect over the telephone - I do believe their father has been engaging in parental alienation tactics for well over a year in an attempt to garner their complete loyalty. I can also say with a fair amount of certainty, that he is well on his way to accomplishing his goal of permanently removing me from their lives if the situation remains unchanged.
I realize that I am partially culpable for the situation we all currently face. A court battle is the last thing I wanted and I avoided it for far too long. My failure to act sooner has caused my children to lose nearly two years of valuable experiences with me, while allowing their father and stepmother free access to warp their minds, steal their souls, and corrupt their character. I was too passive. I failed to respond swiftly and effectively. I failed to take a firm stand the very first time my ex interfered with my parenting time. Of course I had my reasons, but they seem so incredibly frivolous at this moment.
Oprah once said that “you teach people how to treat you.” While I may have taught my ex that I was an easy target by being too compliant with him when it came to my kids, I definitely hope to teach my daughters the power of conviction - the importance of fighting for what you believe in, and that it’s never too late to do the right thing.










